Thursday, April 25, 2013

A Clean, Well-Lighted Place Comparison


The piece "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place" and the short film were very different from each other. There were many similarities, but then there are things that were changed from the piece to the film. Personally, I thought that the directors didn't capture the true meaning of the story. 

When a story sets a setting or a mood, it must be shown as a visual to capture the watcher's attention and inform them how the character feels. For an example, the old man wasn’t sitting in the shadow next to the window. I thought that this was important because it showed that he was in the darkness. It would have made the mood and setting more intense. Some tweaks from the story to the film are normal, but I don't think the directors caught the main idea and the true meaning of the story. 


Mildred


A dystopian world is a place where you could call nightmare world or maybe even Hell. Feelings are forbidden in a dystopian world. For an example, in Fahrenheit 451, no one is to have feelings. In other words, emotionless. In this world, books are banned. One book found in your house and the next thing is your house burning down into massive flames, heavy black smoke polluting in the air, and shreds of wood and paper flying in the sky. Guy Montag was a fire man who enjoyed his job, but you’re thinking about the wrong firefighter. At this time, firefighters start fires in which they find books in. Every night, Guy comes home to his wife Mildred who has got quite an interesting personality.

An ordinary night comes where Mildred takes a whole bottle of sleeping pills. This isn’t any big news to the community. They get as much as 9 calls a night about overdoses. “We get these cases nine or ten a night. Got so many starting a few years ago…” (page 15) a careless operator said. Montag describes this machine making it sound creepy. “They had this machine. They had two machines, really. One of them slid down into your stomach like a black cobra an echoing well looking for all the old water and the old time gathered there….It fed in silence with an occasional sound of inner suffocation and blind searching. It had an eye.” (page 14) This dreadful machine brings Mildred back to life.

The next morning, Mildred acts as if nothing had occurred the night before. Montag reminds her, “You took all the pills in your bottle last night.” but she denies. “Oh [she] wouldn’t do that.” (page 19) This just shows that she is unhappy, but is acting like everything is fine. No one can forget the event when you tried to commit suicide. During the day she acts duplicitous, but at night, the true Mildred comes out. She told on her own husband that he was reading books and ran away from him.

Mildred is clearly unhappy. She fears for being caught and tries to act emotionless. Therefore, Mildred is a very mysterious character. Exposing her true self is confidential and she will never show her true colors. Out of anything, that’s the last thing that she would do: be herself.

Mildred’s actions and personality is based off this dystopian world or in other words, Hell. Is a dystopian world worse than Hell? A dystopian world is frightening and unusual, but there’s nothing worse than Hell.  Not even a dystopian world. “Anyone whose name was not found in the book of life was thrown into the lake of fire.”- Revelation 20:15